Commercial collection agency fees on a real $56,500 aging report

Published rate cards from two commercial agencies run over the same ten overdue invoices, against a flat fee program and a $49 a month tool.

Try it on your own invoice

Draft a compliant collection sequence for a real overdue amount. No card, no signup to preview.

Try the demo
FDCPA Regulation F TCPA No login, no card. A real 45-day campaign, not a sample.

Commercial collection agencies charge a percentage of what they collect, usually 15% to 25% on B2B claims between $3,000 and $50,000, and more on small claims, old debt or debtors abroad. On a realistic $56,500 aging report of ten overdue invoices, that comes to roughly $9,000 to $12,300 if every dollar came back. A flat fee agency would cost about $220 and a $49 a month collections tool would cost $49. Which one is right depends on invoice size, age and whether the customer still answers email.

Most pages on this topic list percentage ranges and stop. This one runs the published rate cards of three providers over the same ten invoices, so you can see what you would owe and what you would keep. Rates were read on each firm's own site in September and October 2026. Where a firm publishes no rate, it is left out.

How much do collection agencies charge?

Collection agencies charge one of three ways: a contingency percentage of money collected, a flat fee per account placed, or a subscription for software that does the follow up in your name. Contingency is the norm for B2B work, with published cards running 25% for the first slice of a claim, falling to 20% and 15% as the amount rises, and 30% to 35% if a lawsuit is needed. Nothing is owed on money not collected.

What percentage do commercial collection agencies take?

The two commercial agencies that publish a full card show the typical shape. Kaplan Group charges 25% on claims of $3,000 to $9,999, 20% from $10,000 to $49,999, 15% from $50,000 and 30% when the debtor is outside the USA. STA International charges 25% on the first $5,000 collected and 20% on the balance, and 30% to 33% for international debtors. Our Kaplan rate breakdown and STA rate breakdown list the minimums and litigation terms.

The same ten invoices, four ways to collect

The sample aging report: three invoices of $500, four of $2,500, two of $10,000 and one of $25,000. That is ten invoices and $56,500 in total, a typical shape for a distributor or services firm with a few slow payers. The fees below assume every invoice is paid in full, which is the ceiling. Real recovery is lower, and contingency fees shrink with it, while flat fees do not.

RouteInvoices it acceptsFee if all paidYou keep
Kaplan GroupClaims from $3,000 and an average claim above $5,000, so three invoices ($10,000, $10,000, $25,000)$9,000 on $45,000 (20% each)$36,000 of $45,000. The $500 and $2,500 invoices stay with you
STA InternationalClaims from $2,500, so seven invoices$12,250 on $55,000 (about 22%)$42,750 of $55,000
Flat fee letter program such as Rocket Receivables Stage OneAll ten, if recent and undisputed$219.50 ($21.95 per account at 10 accounts), owed paid or not$56,280 of $56,500, if everything is paid
DebtAgent StarterAll ten, plus up to 40 more debtors$49 a month, no percentage100% of whatever customers pay

Kaplan's tiers are read here per claim. If a firm sums your placement instead, the rate bands could differ, so confirm in writing before placing. The $500 invoices are the ones nobody will take on a percentage, and they are also the ones a flat fee or software handles at almost no cost.

Why the percentage is not the whole price

Four items move the real cost away from the headline rate.

The recovery rate. A percentage is charged only on collected money, so a 25% agency that recovers 40% of a $10,000 claim costs $1,000, not $2,500. But you also keep only $3,000 of the $4,000 collected, and $6,000 is still outstanding. Ask for recovery rates on claims of your size and age.

Litigation. Kaplan's published rate rises to 30% to 35% if suit is needed, with cost advances starting at $1,300. Court filing and service fees are usually yours on top, so a claim that goes to suit can cost more than the headline rate suggests.

Minimums. Both agencies above decline small invoices. STA says it is generally not a fit for businesses whose debts average under $1,000, and Kaplan wants an average claim above $5,000. If your overdue list is many small invoices, the percentage agencies simply do not apply.

Relationship cost. An agency letter on behalf of a customer you still sell to ends that account about as often as it collects. A friendly reminder in your own name does not. That is why the cheapest route is often the first 30 days of follow up, before an invoice is old enough to place.

What age does to the number

Recovery odds fall with age. A commonly cited industry guide puts recovery above 70% for invoices under 90 days past due and under 15% past 180 days (the figures circulate widely, but no regulator publishes them, so treat them as rough). Practically, an invoice that gets three well timed follow ups at 30, 45 and 60 days rarely needs a contingency agency at all. The same invoice at day 200 costs 25% of whatever remains, and may collect nothing.

That is the logic behind running the sequence early: our cheap collection agency price ranking shows the same ten-invoice math across more providers, and the flat fee collection agency comparison covers who publishes a per account price.

When to pay the percentage anyway

Pay a contingency agency when a single claim is large, the customer has stopped responding, and you have no plan to sell to them again. Percentages are fair for a $25,000 claim that has been ignored for 120 days, because the agency absorbs effort you cannot cheaply replicate, and a lawyer's letter is part of the service. If the customer has disputed the invoice, fix the dispute first. If the dispute is about delivery, a time stamped record such as footage from a loading dock camera set up with motiondetection.com turns a "we never received it" into a settled invoice before it ever reaches an agency.

For the rest, start with software. A flat fee debt collection approach means your cost does not grow with the invoice. DebtAgent drafts a friendly, firm and final email for every overdue invoice from the real amount and days late, you approve, and nothing is taken from what comes in. Plans are on the pricing page, and the contingency collection agency page covers when the percentage route fits. Contractors and suppliers chasing pay apps and retainage can see the same math on one aging report on our construction collection agency fees page.

A quick test before you place anything

Take the aging report and sort it by amount. Invoices under $2,500 are not worth a contingency placement and will often be refused. Invoices between $2,500 and $10,000 at day 60 to 90 are the ones where a follow up sequence is cheapest and most likely to work. Invoices above $10,000 past 120 days with a silent customer are the ones an agency earns its percentage on. Then ask the agency for the rate on your exact amounts and the minimum in writing. Official detail on commercial collection practice is in the Federal Trade Commission's debt collection FAQs, which also explains which rules apply to business debt and which to consumer debt.

Put the three numbers side by side: what the agency takes, what the flat fee costs, and the dollars that came back in a one week test of the sequence. That comparison, not the headline percentage, tells you which route to buy, and the commercial debt collection agency guide shows how to vet one if you do place a claim.

Questions people actually ask

Frequently asked questions

How much do collection agencies charge?

Commercial agencies typically charge 15% to 25% of money collected on B2B claims between $3,000 and $50,000, with 30% or more for lawsuits or debtors abroad. Flat fee programs charge about $15 to $22 per account placed. Collections software such as DebtAgent costs a flat $49 to $898 a month with no percentage.

What percentage do commercial collection agencies take?

Published cards show 25% on the first slice of a claim, falling to 20% above $10,000 and 15% above $50,000. Kaplan Group charges 25%, 20% and 15% by claim size. STA International charges 25% on the first $5,000 and 20% on the rest. Debtors outside the US cost 30% to 33%.

Do collection agencies charge if they collect nothing?

Contingency agencies charge nothing if nothing is collected. Flat fee programs charge per account whether or not the debtor pays, and litigation cost advances, which start around $1,300 at Kaplan, are separate. Always ask what is owed on a failed placement in writing.

Is it cheaper to use software than a collection agency?

For invoices under about $10,000 that are less than 120 days late, yes. Software costs a fixed monthly fee and you keep every dollar collected. An agency percentage is cheaper only when a large claim is ignored and you need a legal letter or suit.

Keep reading
  • More on accounts receivable aging report: An aging report is the one page that tells you which customers are quietly turning into bad debt. Here is what each column means, what a real one looks like, and the action that belongs to every bucket.
  • More on cheap collection agency: Cheap depends on invoice size. Every published collection agency price, flat fee and contingency, worked on $500, $2,500 and $10,000 invoices, with the conditions that change the real cost.
  • Related page: Construction collection agency
  • Related page: Flat Fee Debt Collection